On Not Knowing How I’m Feeling

Those who know me know that I’m big on not knowing.  I mean, there are some issues that I come down hard and fast on, but generally speaking I give the benefit of the doubt way more than I should, and I allow for a fair amount of leeway when scaling orthodoxy.  I’ve been wrong far to often to deny an intelligent person’s reasoned opinion on most matters.  Unless they’re wrong, which seems to happen all the time on the internet.  People being wrong on the internet keeps me up at night because I’ll argue my case long after they say “nope, that’s just the way it is.”  Mostly, I like the debate, the competition of it, like intellectual wrestling or mental bocce ball.  At the end of it though, as long as I’m not caught up in the fight, I’m happy to allow for the possibility (however slim) that they may be right.

This is a dancing pickle:

I am a master of the non-sequitur.

So yeah, to bring it back closer to the point, and in defiance of all those who hold me in high esteem (both of you – what up!), I don’t always have the answer (although I’m usually willing to fake it convincingly).  The big question that I haven’t been able to fake a convincing answer to lately is “how are you doing?”  I could say Fine, but I don’t think I am.  I don’t know whether that’s a lie or not, so I don’t know how to play it off.  It probably is, though, and it’s lame, so I don’t usually go that route.  The most honest answer I can give right now is “I don’t know,” but people just keep looking at me like they’re expecting more, or like they feel like I’m not trusting them or the authenticity of their concern.

It’s a weird feeling not to know how you’re feeling.  I feel like it’s something I should know.  As much as I might pass myself off as an authority on a wide variety of subjects, I am definitely the world’s foremost authority on what’s going on inside my head.

I have no clue.

My friends and family ask me and I’m left with the blank stare of a McDonalds addict who was just asked what percentage of their recommended daily caloric intake they just consumed in a single sitting.  I’m freaking out but I’m not.  I’m anxious and upset but I’m not.  I’m tired.  I’m not blowing people off when I say I don’t know how I’m feeling.  I really don’t know.  As much as I’m cool with not knowing how the End Times will play out, or who’s allowed into heaven and who’s not, or what my cats are really thinking when they look at me like I might be food, I’m not cool with not having answer to this question.  As I consider it, I’m coming to believe that it’s primarily because of the pressure I feel to have an answer.  To appease the people that love me and care about me and want to offer their support.  I know you want to help, and it hurts not to be able to let you.  If I knew what would help – if I had a clue what I was feeling – I’d tell you.

(There’s a long winded pity party for you, some classic 90s blogging.)

Can we make that okay?  Can “know thyself” take a backseat to “be thyself” for a while?

I’m going to talk for a second about the friends of Job tonight.  Generally speaking, they’re raging douchebags with incredibly bad and ill-informed advice (been there, can’t come down to hard on them for it), but you’ve got to give them this: when Job’s life was going to pot, this is what they did: “they sat on the ground with him for seven days and seven nights. No one said a word to him, because they saw how great his suffering was. [Job 2:13]” They dropped what they were doing and came to be with him.  They don’t become jerkasses until they start pushing and prodding at “what he did wrong to deserve it”.  They had it right the first time.  They were just there.  Actions are love.  Presence is love.

I think that as humans when we see something that’s broken we either want to poke it or fix it.  We don’t do well with things that are too sensitive to poke and too convoluted and messed up to fix.  We try to package it in a way that we can understand then make it better.  Sometimes we can’t make it better, sometimes it doesn’t fit into a neat box.  I think deep down we know that and we try to take care of other people’s issues as a way of cathartically dealing with our own. Can we [I] learn how to offer support without offering advice?  Without needing to get in there and clean up the mess like a some kind of superhero emotional janitor?  Let’s be Broken people together.  I know it will get better.  I’ll sort it out.  We’ll sort it out.  All I really know is that for now I’m lost in my head, and I’d just appreciate some good company while I wander.

Dancing pickle.


About Aaron Mark Reimer

Aaron Mark Reimer was born in 1980 on Prince Edward Island, Canada, and his parents promptly moved him west to Ontario. He is a pastor, a writer, a speaker, a musician, and a bit of a geek. Published works include The Art of Being Broken, Worshipping Through John: A Devotional For Praise Teams, and a short story about going to Jupiter with his dad that he wrote when he was seven. He has one wife (Vanessa), two sons (Dúnadan and Taliesin), and many cats. Follow him on Twitter as @IAmAnErrorMaker

Posted on March 20, 2011, in Ramblings, Theological Reflections. Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.

  1. I could certainly wander with you. Sitting with you I could do too. Not as good at not saying anything but I would certainly give that a good try. Just know that you don’t have to answer that question right now and it’s OK.

  2. I’m hanging out on the ground with you, Aaron- quietly. I don’t think there are words to adequately affirm the reality that being trumps knowing.

    I so, so wish our families lived closer. 😦

    I hope you don’t mind me crashing your blogs; I really miss you guys.


  3. I stoked the campfire. Got a bag of mental marshmallows. We can light ’em up, stuff our cheeks full, and not say word. Together.

    Assuming the lotus position. Now. Listening…

  4. Chubby Bunny.

    • You guys are funny :). Also, I should point out that if I was blogging against Kane, he’d be winning blogging. But I’m not. He has too much of a head start. And I don’t like not winning.

  5. I would love it if you would blog with me. We’d both be winning then. What do you think? Are you willing to co-author?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: